top of page
Writer's pictureGame Nights Galore

Create your Custom Murder Mystery Game with Game Nights Galore

Updated: Oct 31

Custom Murder Mystery Game

If you've ever dreamed of hosting a memorable and engaging event, a custom murder mystery game could be your perfect solution. At Game Nights Galore, we specialize in crafting personalized mystery experiences that are easy to host, fun to play and sure to captivate your guests. Here's how you can create a unique murder mystery game that will leave everyone talking.


Why Choose Game Nights Galore?


Key Features

At Game Nights Galore, we pride ourselves on offering fully customizable games. Whether you're planning a small gathering or a large event, we can tailor the experience to fit your needs. Our games typically take 1-3 weeks to prepare, depending on the complexity, and are designed as mingle mystery games. This format allows guests to become both suspects and sleuths, mingling throughout the party to gather clues. Plus, the host can join in the fun since the killer doesn't even know they're the killer until the end!


Crafting Your Custom Murder Mystery Game


Step-by-Step Process

Creating a custom murder mystery game with Game Nights Galore is straightforward:


  1. Purchase the Custom Game Product: Start by selecting the custom game product that fits your needs. Each game includes up to 24 suspects.

  2. Add Additional Suspects: If your party exceeds 24 guests, you can purchase additional suspects in packs of 12.

  3. Complete the Custom Game Form: After your purchase, you'll receive an email with instructions on completing the custom game form. This is where you'll detail your customization requests, including the theme, plot, and suspect information. You can add as little or as much as you like and we will fill in the rest!

  4. Review and Confirmation: Once we receive your form, we'll review it and reach out with any questions to ensure we have all the details we need.

  5. Receive Your Game PDF: When your game is complete, we'll email you a PDF of the game, ready for you to print and play.


Customization Options

Our customization options are extensive. You can personalize every aspect of the game, from the names and backgrounds of the suspects to the overarching theme and plot. This ensures your game is unique and perfectly suited to your event.


  • Game Name: Choose a unique and catchy name for your mystery game that fits your event’s theme.

  • Theme: Whether it's a classic whodunit, a fantasy adventure, or a sci-fi thriller, you can select any theme that suits your party.

  • Plot: Create an engaging storyline with twists and turns tailored to your preferences and event setting.

  • Suspect Names: Personalize the names of each suspect to reflect the tone and theme of your game.

  • Suspect Backgrounds: Develop detailed backstories for each suspect, adding depth and intrigue to the characters.

  • Setting: Define the location where the mystery unfolds, whether it's a haunted mansion, a bustling casino, or a serene garden.

  • Victim: Decide who the victim will be and how their demise adds to the mystery.

  • Motive: Tailor the motives for each suspect, making sure they align with their backstories and relationships.

  • Costume Suggestions: Provide costume ideas for your guests to enhance the immersive experience of the game.

  • Game Duration: Choose the difficulty level and sleuth time that best matches the pace you want for your event.


Custom Murder Mystery Game

Game Themes and Examples

We can design a game around any theme imaginable. Here are a few examples of past custom games we've created:


  • The Crimson Rose (Fantasy Wedding Rehearsal): A whimsical tea party in an enchanted forest where magical creatures gather, and a royal advisor is mysteriously murdered.

  • Mississippi Madness (Family Vacation/Birthday Party): A family gathering turns deadly when an uninvited cousin is found dead and a pontoon boat is destroyed.

  • Grillin & Killin (BBQ Birthday Party): A beloved flight attendant's 50th birthday BBQ ends in tragedy with her untimely death and the theft of a valuable gift.

  • The Golden Gambit (Black Tie 50th Birthday): During a high-stakes casino game, a billionaire collapses from poison, and a critical USB drive goes missing.

  • Masqollide (Time Travel 25th Birthday): Guests from the 1700s and modern times converge at a mystical manor, leading to the poisoning of a brilliant inventor.

  • Guess Who's Coming to Dentin (Baby Reveal): Guests play a game that will reveal the host is having a baby.


Support and Resources

We provide exceptional support to ensure your event runs smoothly. You can reach us via email, chat, or through our social media platforms on Etsy, YouTube, X, Instagram, Facebook, and Pinterest. Each game we create has a Pinterest board filled with additional party ideas so you can get inspired!


Additional Suspects

Pricing and Packages

Our custom games are priced at $175 for up to 24 suspects, with the option to add more suspects as needed (Packs of 12 for $20). This includes a fully personalized game delivered as a PDF, ready for you to print and enjoy.


Hosting a custom murder mystery game with Game Nights Galore is a fun and engaging way to entertain your guests. With our easy-to-follow process, extensive customization options, and outstanding support, you'll be able to create an unforgettable event tailored specifically to your needs.


Ready to get started? Visit our website today and let us help you bring your murder mystery party to life!


11 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page