top of page
  • Writer's pictureGame Nights Galore

Organizing the Perfect Murder Mystery Party: A Step-by-Step Guide

For those looking to craft a suspense-filled evening, Game Nights Galore is here to lead you through the maze of planning the ultimate Murder Mystery party.

Party Time

Mystery, intrigue, and a pinch of drama! Who wouldn’t love a murder mystery party? As the latest trend in event planning, these gatherings guarantee laughter, suspense, and plenty of fun memories. But, orchestrating a flawless event can seem as complex as solving the murder itself. Don’t fret! With an easy to follow timeline, we've laid out everything you need to know to organize, from invites to the climactic reveal.

2-4 Weeks Out: The Groundwork

  • Choose Your Game: Start by selecting a murder mystery game that aligns with your guest count and desired theme. At Game Nights Galore, we offer a wide variety that caters to every group, setting, and period and can quickly customize any game for your needs.

  • Set the Date and Venue: Decide on a date that suits most of your guests. For venues, a home setting is great, but you could also explore cozy cafés or reserved spaces to up the ambiance. Outdoor spaces are great for murder mystery games, especially with a large amount of people attending. You want to host in a place where guests can move around.

  • Determine your Guests: Who do you want to invite? Start jotting down names.

  • Craft the Perfect Invites: Tailor your invitations to hint at the theme. Maybe a faux newspaper clipping reporting a crime? Include date, time, venue, and even costume ideas. The more immersive, the better! Tip: A personal touch, like handwritten notes or a wax seal, can add an air of authenticity and suspense.

  • Set your budget: Determining how much you are willing to spend on an event will help you with decisions that need to be made and having a set budget will make sure you don't overspend.

1-2 Weeks Out: Dive into Details


  • Character Assignments: Send out character assignments from the game kit. This allows your guests to get familiar with their roles and to plan their costumes accordingly and really get into their role. With Game Nights Galore murder mystery games there are no lines or scripts for guests to memorize, so even the shyest guest can play!

  • Menu Planning: Themed food and drinks can add to the allure. Consider "Bloody" Mary cocktails, dagger-shaped cookies, or meals that align with your chosen era. Plan out your entire menu which will help you prep food in advance, or make your event a pot luck and send out a sign up sheet with your invitations.

  • Set the Scene: Plan out the décor. Dim lighting, red velvet drapes, and subtle background music can be wonderful additions. Don’t forget props that are crucial to the game plot! Pinterest is a great place to get ideas for just about any theme! Tip: Visit Game Nights Galore's music section for the perfect playlist to set the mood.

Party Dog

Few Days Before: The Final Prep

  • Send a Reminder: People can forget. A gentle reminder, perhaps with a cryptic clue or a faux news update on the murder, can reignite the excitement.

  • Procure and Prep: Plan out a timeline for all the things you want to accomplish. Buy all the necessary ingredients and props. Do a test run of your setting, ensuring that everything from seating to game-related stations is in place. Tip: Consider creating a ‘Murder Mystery Memory’ photo album or digital collage for guests.

  • Know the Game: As the host, you should familiarize yourself with the game's flow. If you can, PRACTICE! It's important to understand the clues, the story, and potential questions participants might ask. I find it best to have clipboards ready for each guest that includes their suspect sheet, the rules page, pencil and a blank page for notes and the reveal slip for when they are ready to guess who the murderer is. Many guests get really into sleuthing, so notes will be taken. Setting this up in advance will go a long way on making sure you are familiar with the game and in getting guests ready for action!


Day of the Event: Showtime!

  • Setting Up: Arrive early. Ensure that everything is in place – from the food and drinks to the props, ambiance and music. If you have people to volunteer to set up, have them come early!

  • Guest Arrival: As guests arrive, hand them any game-related material they might need. Give them time to mingle, setting the stage for interactions. I like to have a mini game ready with fun "Get to know you" questions. I place them in bowls around the house or where everyone will mingle prior to the game beginning. This breaks the ice for guest who don't know each other.

  • Start the Game: Once everyone's settled, kick things off! Set the scene with a dramatic reading of the murder or a short skit and let your guest mingle.

  • Facilitate: Move the game along, ensuring everyone's involved and the rules are followed. You're the detective and the director! There are times people will break off into conversations. You want this as it makes for a great party! I recommend putting a timer on the game play time.

The Climax: The Big Reveal

Big Reveal

  • Let the Accusations Fly: Once all clues are gathered, let participants present their theories. This can be the most entertaining part, so ensure everyone gets a chance.

  • The Unveiling: Finally, unveil the murderer. Applaud the participants who guessed correctly and offer a prize if you wish.

  • Debrief: Discuss the clues and interactions that led to the climax. It's also a great time for photographs and sharing stories.

  • Let your guests continue to mingle and have fun.

While the idea of hosting a murder mystery party might sound daunting, with a little preparation and guidance from Game Nights Galore, it can be an event to remember. Dive into our range of murder mystery games, and with this guide, you’re ready to give your guests an experience they’ll be talking about for years to come.

Happy sleuthing!

140 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page