The Naughty List: How to Host an EPIC Naughty or Nice Christmas Traitors Party

By Game Nights Galore

Welcome to the ultimate guide to hosting a Naughty or Nice Christmas game night! If you love the strategy, deception, alliances, and suspense of a Traitors-style game, The Naughty List takes that same type of social strategy experience and gives it a completely festive Christmas twist.

This isn't your average sit-down Christmas game! The Naughty List is a high-energy, immersive mingle experience where guests are secretly divided into Naughty and Nice. Players mingle, form alliances, compete in Reindeer Games, accuse one another at Santa's Workshop, and try to figure out who belongs on the Naughty List before it's too late.

And the Christmas theme gives you SO many possibilities for creating the party around the game! Think Naughty or Nice invitations, Santa's Workshop decorations, Christmas cocktails, Reindeer Games, festive foods, Christmas music, ridiculous prizes, ugly sweaters, and plenty of opportunities to discover which of your friends has been lying to you all night.

From customizing the game setup to Reindeer Games, invitations, decorations, themed food and drinks, music, and hosting ideas, this guide will walk you through everything you need to host an EPIC Naughty or Nice Christmas party.

Check out our Christmas social strategy game, The Naughty List, which puts you and your friends right in the middle of the action. It is simple to set up, highly adaptable, works for groups of 6 or more, and can be customized for everything from a family Christmas gathering to an adult holiday party or Christmas weekend. 

What is The Naughty List?

Imagine a Traitors-style game brought to life at your Christmas party, but instead of searching for Traitors, everyone is trying to determine who secretly belongs on The Naughty List.

The Naughty List is an interactive, mingle-style competition where players receive one of two secret roles: Naughty or Nice.

The Nice must work together to identify and eliminate the Naughty hiding among them. Meanwhile, the Naughty must blend in, manipulate suspicions, and secretly eliminate the Nice without getting caught.

Throughout the game, players mingle and form alliances, compete in Reindeer Games, earn special Reward Cards, and gather at Santa's Workshop to discuss their suspicions and vote someone out.

Meanwhile, the Naughty are secretly working against everyone else.

The game continues until the remaining players believe they've eliminated everyone who is Naughty. If they're correct, the Nice win. If even one Naughty player survives to the Final Decision, the Naughty win.

It's Christmas cheer mixed with strategy, suspicion, competition, and a LOT of questionable behavior from people who insist they're Nice.

How is The Naughty List Played?

Here's a quick breakdown of how the game unfolds:

1. Role Assignment: Players secretly become either Naughty or Nice. Roles can be assigned by the Host or selected blindly at the beginning of the game.

2. Mingle & Strategy: Players interact, form alliances, watch one another, and begin deciding who they think might secretly be Naughty.

3. Reindeer Games: Everyone participates in a Reindeer Game where players have the opportunity to earn special Reward Cards.

4. Santa's Workshop: Players openly discuss their suspicions and vote to eliminate the person they believe is Naughty.

5. Mingle Banishment: The Naughty secretly choose one Nice player to banish.

6. Repeat Until the Final Decision: The rounds continue until the remaining players decide whether they believe all of the Naughty have been eliminated.

Reindeer Games aren't just for bragging rights. Players have the opportunity to earn special rewards, including a Stocking, which protects a player from Banishment, Mistletoe, which allows a player to cast two votes at Santa's Workshop, and Frozen Vote, which can cancel another player's vote.

The key to making it onto the Nice List? Trust carefully.

Why Play The Naughty List?

If you're looking for something different from the traditional Christmas party games everyone has already played, The Naughty List gives your guests something to do throughout the entire party.

• Interactive & Social: Guests aren't stuck sitting around a table. They're mingling, strategizing, competing, making accusations, and forming alliances.

• Perfect for Christmas: Reindeer Games, Santa's Workshop, Naughty and Nice roles, Mistletoe, Stockings, and Banishment to the Island of Misfit Toys make the game naturally fit a Christmas party.

• Great for Groups: The game is designed for 6 or more players, making it easy to use for different-sized gatherings.

• Easy to Customize: Choose your own Reindeer Games, change the timing, create your own Christmas theme, and make the experience as competitive, silly, or dramatic as your group wants.

• Full of Suspense: Nobody knows who is Naughty, who is Nice, or whether the person loudly accusing everyone else is actually the biggest liar in the room.

• Replayable: Change the secret roles, Reindeer Games, alliances, and players, and the entire night can unfold differently the next time you play.

Ways to Customize The Naughty List

Want to make your Naughty or Nice Christmas party completely your own? Here are some fun ways to customize the experience:

1. Choose How Roles Are Assigned: Pre-assign Naughty and Nice roles, let guests blindly choose their Role Cards, hide roles inside Christmas crackers, or place them inside tiny wrapped presents for guests to open privately.

2. Control the Timing: The Host can shorten or extend phases based on the party. If everyone is deeply involved in strategizing, let them mingle longer. If you have dinner or another activity planned, keep things moving. The game can last from a few hours to several days depending on your event.

3. Choose ANY Reindeer Games: Use physical games, puzzles, logic challenges, classic Christmas party games, or ridiculous competitions your particular group will love.

4. Make It an Ugly Sweater Party: Tell everyone to arrive in their best ugly Christmas sweater, then give prizes for Ugliest, Most Creative, Most Festive, and Most Questionable.

5. Go North Pole Formal: Skip the ugly sweaters and turn the night into an elegant Christmas party with cocktail attire, candlelight, greenery, velvet ribbon, gold bells, and vintage Christmas decorations.

6. Create a Christmas Weekend: Hosting family or friends for several days? Spread the game throughout the weekend with a Reindeer Game before dinner, Santa's Workshop later that night, and another round the following morning.

7. Turn the Host Into Santa: The Host can guide the night as Santa, Mrs. Claus, Head Elf, or Keeper of the Naughty List.

8. Make the Role Reveal Part of Christmas: Hide roles inside stockings, ornaments, gift boxes, envelopes hung on the tree, or Christmas crackers.

9. Add Awards: Give prizes for Best Naughty Player, Best Nice Player, Best Liar, Best Detective, Most Dramatic Accusation, and Person Most Likely to Actually Be on Santa's Naughty List.

10. Create Your Own North Pole: Rename different areas of your house Santa's Workshop, Reindeer Stables, Mrs. Claus' Kitchen, The North Pole, Elf Headquarters, and The Island of Misfit Toys.

Reindeer Games for The Naughty List

Reindeer Games are a key part of The Naughty List, so this is your chance to use classic Christmas games, team competitions, puzzles, or completely ridiculous challenges.

Easy & Quick Reindeer Games

1. Reindeer Ring Toss

Have one player wear inflatable or felt reindeer antlers while teammates attempt to toss rings onto them. Give each team a limited number of throws or one minute to land as many rings as possible.

If you're playing with particularly competitive adults, make the antler-wearing Reindeer slowly move around.

2. Candy Cane Hook

Give each player a candy cane to hold in their mouth. Without using their hands, players must use the hook of their candy cane to pick up other candy canes and move them from one bowl to another. The player or team that transfers the most before time runs out wins.

3. Snowball Toss

Use white ping-pong balls, pom-poms, or soft fake snowballs. Set up buckets at different distances and assign each one a point value. Players have a limited number of "snowballs" to score as many points as possible.

4. Christmas Memory Match

Create pairs of cards featuring ornaments, stockings, candy canes, snowmen, Santa hats, presents, reindeer, Christmas trees, and other holiday images. Place them face down and have players race to find matching pairs.

5. Name That Christmas Song

Play the first few seconds of popular Christmas songs and see who can identify them fastest. For a harder version, play instrumental versions only. For an even harder version, read one line of the lyrics dramatically instead of playing the song.

Longer & Harder Reindeer Games

6. Wrap It Up

Give teams a box, wrapping paper, scissors, and tape. They have a limited amount of time to wrap the present as neatly as possible. Sounds easy. Now make everyone wear oven mitts.

7. Build Santa's Sleigh

Give teams cardboard, tape, wrapping paper, bows, paper plates, and other craft supplies. They have ten minutes to create the best miniature sleigh. Judge based on creativity, construction, and whether Santa would actually trust it with eight reindeer and several billion presents.

8. Christmas Code Breaker

Give players an encrypted message from Santa and a cipher key. Messages could include: THE NAUGHTY ARE AMONG YOU, TRUST NO ELF, THE REWARD IS HIDDEN UNDER THE TREE

SOMEONE NICE IS ABOUT TO BE BANISHED. The first team to correctly decode the message wins.

9. North Pole Scavenger Hunt

Hide Christmas objects throughout the party such as a bell, candy cane, tiny stocking, reindeer, ornament, bow, snowflake, Santa hat, and miniature present. Give teams riddles that lead them from one object to the next. The final clue leads to Santa's missing present or a hidden Reward.

10. Escape Santa's Workshop

Create a Christmas-themed mini escape room. Hide clues inside presents, ornaments, stockings, Christmas cards, books, or cookie tins. Players must solve riddles and codes to discover the final combination and unlock Santa's Workshop before time runs out.

Unique Naughty or Nice Invitation Ideas

Start building the theme before anyone arrives.

1. Official Naughty List Notice: Send each guest a formal letter stating that their current status on Santa's List is UNDER REVIEW and their presence is required for a final determination.

2. North Pole Summons: Create an official-looking letter from Santa requesting the guest report to the North Pole for questioning.

3. Naughty or Nice Scratch-Off: Create a scratch-off area on the invitation that reveals NAUGHTY? NICE? YOU'LL FIND OUT.

4. Christmas Ornament Invitation: Write or attach the party information to an ornament and hand-deliver it to guests.

5. Wrapped Present Invitation: Put the invitation inside a tiny wrapped box with a tag reading DO NOT OPEN UNTIL CHRISTMAS... OR NOW.

6. Santa's Confidential File: Place the invitation inside a red folder marked CONFIDENTIAL: NAUGHTY LIST INVESTIGATION and add a few humorous pieces of "evidence."

7. Christmas Cracker Invitation: Place the party details inside a Christmas cracker along with a paper crown and small treat.

8. Elf Telegram: Create a message from the North Pole stating that Santa's list has been compromised and the recipient is required to report immediately.

9. Naughty List Scroll: Print everyone's names on a long parchment-style list, circle the guest's name in red, and attach the party information underneath.

10. Video From the North Pole: Create a short video showing Christmas lights, wrapped presents, a half-finished Naughty List, and a message announcing: SANTA NEEDS YOUR HELP. THE NAUGHTY HAVE INFILTRATED THE NICE.

Decorating Ideas

Set the scene for an immersive Naughty or Nice Christmas experience:

1. Santa's Workshop: Create a designated area for eliminations using wrapped presents, toy-making supplies, Christmas lights, wooden toys, stockings, ribbon, and a large SANTA'S WORKSHOP sign.

2. The Giant Naughty List: Create an oversized scroll, chalkboard, or framed board with every guest's name. Move names to Naughty or Nice as roles are eventually revealed.

3. Naughty & Nice Color Scheme: Divide your décor between traditional Christmas red and green or use red for Naughty and white, silver, or gold for Nice.

4. North Pole Directional Signs: Create signs pointing toward Santa's Workshop, Reindeer Stables, Elf Headquarters, Mrs. Claus' Kitchen, and Island of Misfit Toys.

5. Suspicious Stockings: Hang a stocking for every guest. Use them for names, secret messages, party favors, or even role distribution.

6. Santa's Evidence Board: Add guest photos to a board and connect them with red and green string. Let players add sticky notes with suspicions throughout the night.

7. Wrapped Presents Everywhere: Wrap empty boxes in coordinated paper and stack them around Santa's Workshop, beneath the tree, near the bar, and around the room. Empty boxes create a huge visual impact without buying more decorations.

8. Mistletoe Everywhere: Since Mistletoe is one of the game's special Rewards, incorporate it into wreaths, table decorations, place settings, and doorways. Just don't assume someone standing beneath it is Nice.

9. Island of Misfit Toys: Create an area for eliminated players using mismatched toys, old stuffed animals, quirky decorations, and a sign announcing WELCOME TO THE ISLAND OF MISFIT TOYS.

10. Santa's Mailroom: Fill a table with envelopes, stamps, postcards, letters to Santa, packages, twine, and a mailbox. Use it as decoration, a drink station, or even a place for players to leave secret accusations.

Details to Make Your Christmas Party EPIC

1. Give Everyone an Elf Name: Put ridiculous North Pole names on guests' drink tags or place cards.

2. Create Naughty & Nice Name Tags: Let everyone choose what they claim to be when they arrive. Their sticker has absolutely nothing to do with their secret role.

3. Ring Sleigh Bells for Santa's Workshop: Use a set of bells every time players need to gather. By round two, that sound will immediately get everyone's attention.

4. Move Eliminated Players to the Island of Misfit Toys: Give them a fun place to continue eating, drinking, and watching the game without interfering.

5. Create Santa's Surveillance Board: Take Polaroids or print photos of guests and let players write accusations underneath them.

6. Hide Tiny Elves Around the House: Turn them into décor, a scavenger hunt, or simply an ongoing joke.

7. Give Banished Players Coal: Hand each eliminated player a piece of fake coal or a small bag of black candy.

8. Create Personalized Stockings: Hang inexpensive stockings labeled with each player's name and use them throughout the game.

9. Make a North Pole Photo Booth: Add Santa hats, elf ears, antlers, signs, wrapped presents, oversized candy canes, and Naughty or Nice props.

10. Take a Naughty & Nice Group Photo: Take one before the game and another after the final roles are revealed. The second picture may involve considerably less trust.

Naughty or Nice Christmas Food Ideas

The easiest Christmas party foods are familiar favorites with a Naughty or Nice twist.

1. Naughty & Nice Charcuterie Board: Divide a large board into two sides. Fill the Nice side with lighter-colored cheeses, fruit, crackers, and white chocolate. Fill the Naughty side with dark meats, olives, spicy cheeses, dark chocolate, and red berries.

2. Santa's Sliders: Serve mini cheeseburgers or pulled pork sliders with festive picks.

3. Reindeer Bites: Make cocktail meatballs with pretzel "antlers" or simply rename your favorite meatball recipe.

4. North Pole Flatbreads: Create Christmas-tree-shaped flatbreads with pesto, mozzarella, tomatoes, and other colorful toppings.

5. Mistletoe Crostini: Top toasted baguette with goat cheese, cranberry sauce, and fresh herbs.

6. Elf Snack Board: Fill a grazing board with cheese cubes, crackers, fruit, pretzels, popcorn, nuts, candy, and other easy foods guests can grab while mingling.

7. Coal Cheese Balls: Make mini cheese balls coated in crushed black tortilla chips, black sesame seeds, or dark seasoning and label them Lumps of Coal.

8. Christmas Tree Skewers: Arrange antipasto, fruit, or caprese skewers in the shape of a Christmas tree.

9. Santa's Workshop Pizza: Make individual pizzas and let guests choose their toppings before the game begins.

10. Naughty Nachos: Build a loaded nacho platter with jalapeños and spicy toppings. Add a milder Nice Nachos version beside it.

Christmas Dessert & Treat Ideas

1. Lumps of Coal: Make chocolate truffles, Oreo balls, or brownie bites and roll them in dark cookie crumbs.

2. Naughty List Cookies: Decorate rectangular sugar cookies to look like miniature lists with tiny names written in icing.

3. Nice List Cookies: Create white and gold versions with stars, snowflakes, or halos.

4. Reindeer Cupcakes: Chocolate cupcakes topped with pretzel antlers, candy eyes, and red noses.

5. Santa Hat Brownies: Top brownie bites with strawberries and whipped cream to resemble Santa hats.

6. Mistletoe Macarons: Green macarons filled with white chocolate or vanilla buttercream and decorated with tiny red berries.

7. Snowball Cookies: Powdered sugar cookies piled high on a silver or white tray.

8. North Pole Cake: Decorate a layer cake with red and white stripes, peppermint candies, and a North Pole sign.

9. Christmas Light Cupcakes: Pipe strands of frosting across cupcakes and add colorful candies as Christmas bulbs.

10. Naughty or Nice Dessert Cups: Create two versions of the same dessert. Try dark chocolate mousse for Naughty and white chocolate mousse for Nice.

Cocktails for Your Naughty or Nice Party

1. The Naughty List

A dark red Christmas cocktail for guests who have accepted their fate.

Ingredients:

• 2 oz vodka

• 1 oz cranberry juice

• 1 oz pomegranate juice

• 1/2 oz lime juice

• 1/2 oz simple syrup

• Fresh cranberries

Instructions:

• Shake vodka, cranberry juice, pomegranate juice, lime juice, and simple syrup with ice.

• Strain into a chilled glass.

• Garnish with fresh cranberries.

2. The Nice List

A light, sparkling cocktail that looks considerably more innocent.

Ingredients:

• 1 oz elderflower liqueur

• 3 oz prosecco

• 1 oz white cranberry juice

• Splash of club soda

• Rosemary sprig

Instructions:

• Add elderflower liqueur and white cranberry juice to a glass with ice.

• Top with prosecco and a splash of club soda.

• Garnish with rosemary.

3. Mistletoe Mischief

Sweet, tart, festive, and possibly responsible for some poor decisions at Santa's Workshop.

Ingredients:

• 1 1/2 oz gin

• 1 oz cranberry juice

• 3/4 oz lime juice

• 1/2 oz simple syrup

• Club soda

Instructions:

• Shake gin, cranberry juice, lime juice, and simple syrup with ice.

• Strain over fresh ice.

• Top with club soda.

• Garnish with cranberries and rosemary.

4. Rudolph's Revenge

A festive twist with a little kick.

Ingredients:

• 2 oz bourbon

• 1 oz cranberry juice

• 1/2 oz orange juice

• 1/2 oz maple syrup

• 2 dashes bitters

Instructions:

• Shake all ingredients with ice.

• Strain over a large ice cube.

• Garnish with an orange peel.

5. The Frozen Vote

An icy blue cocktail inspired by one of the game's Reward Cards.

Ingredients:

• 1 1/2 oz vodka

• 1 oz blue curaçao

• 1 oz lemonade

• 1/2 oz lime juice

• Club soda

Instructions:

• Shake vodka, blue curaçao, lemonade, and lime juice with ice.

• Pour over fresh ice.

• Top with club soda.

• Garnish with a lime wheel.

Naughty or Nice Christmas Mocktails

1. Nice List Fizz: White cranberry juice, sparkling water, elderflower syrup, and rosemary.

2. Rudolph Punch: Cranberry juice, orange juice, ginger ale, and fresh cranberries.

3. North Pole Punch: Lemonade, white cranberry juice, lemon-lime soda, and frozen cranberries.

4. Mistletoe Mule: Cranberry juice, lime juice, and ginger beer served over ice with rosemary.

5. Grinchy & Naughty: Limeade, pineapple juice, lemon-lime soda, and a splash of grenadine.

Serve the mocktails in the same festive glassware and with the same garnishes as everything else. Nobody should be able to identify the nonalcoholic drink from across the room.

The Ultimate Naughty or Nice Christmas Playlist

Set the mood with a Christmas playlist that mixes classics, party songs, and a few selections that become much funnier when half the room is secretly lying.

1. Santa Claus Is Coming to Town - The Jackson 5

2. You’re a Mean One, Mr. Grinch - Thurl Ravenscroft

3. Last Christmas - Wham!

4. Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree - Brenda Lee

5. Jingle Bell Rock - Bobby Helms

6. Santa Baby - Eartha Kitt

7. Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) - Darlene Love

8. Run Rudolph Run - Chuck Berry

9. Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays - *NSYNC

10. Underneath the Tree - Kelly Clarkson

11. Sleigh Ride - The Ronettes

12. Step Into Christmas - Elton John

13. Mistletoe - Justin Bieber

14. One More Sleep - Leona Lewis

15. Christmas Wrapping - The Waitresses

16. Man With the Bag - Jessie J

17. Santa Tell Me - Ariana Grande

18. My Only Wish (This Year) - Britney Spears

19. Cozy Little Christmas - Katy Perry

20. Candy Cane Lane - Sia

21. Merry Christmas Everyone - Shakin' Stevens

22. Feliz Navidad - José Feliciano

23. A Holly Jolly Christmas - Burl Ives

24. It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year - Andy Williams

25. All I Want for Christmas Is You - Mariah Carey

Tips for the Host to Make Your Naughty or Nice Party EPIC

Make your Naughty List game night unforgettable with these hosting tips:

1. Set the Mood Before Guests Arrive: Have the Christmas lights glowing, music playing, drinks ready, and Santa's Workshop set up before anyone walks through the door.

2. Make Role Selection Fun: Use wrapped boxes, stockings, ornaments, Christmas crackers, or wax-sealed North Pole envelopes instead of simply handing everyone a card.

3. Encourage Players to Mingle: The Mingle Phases are when suspicions develop and alliances form. Give players enough time to talk privately and strategize.

4. Choose Reindeer Games Your Group Will Actually Enjoy: Don't choose a complicated physical challenge for a group that would rather solve puzzles. Mix quick, silly games with more competitive challenges.

5. Make Santa's Workshop a BIG Deal: This is where everyone openly discusses suspicions and votes someone out. Change the music, ring sleigh bells, gather everyone together, and let each player reveal their vote one at a time.

6. Make Banishments Fun: Give eliminated players coal, move their photo to the Island of Misfit Toys, remove their stocking, or ceremoniously cross their name off Santa's List.

7. Use Music Cues: Pick a specific song, bell, or sound effect for Santa's Workshop, Banishment reveals, and Reindeer Games.

8. Keep Eliminated Players Included: Give them a designated Island of Misfit Toys where they can continue enjoying the party and watching the game without revealing information.

9. Have a Signature Drink & Snack Ready: A Naughty List cocktail and bowl of Lumps of Coal immediately introduce the theme when guests arrive.

10. Give Out Awards at the End: Award Best Naughty Player, Best Nice Player, Best Liar, Best Detective, Most Dramatic Player, Best Christmas Outfit, and Most Likely to Actually Receive Coal This Year.

Ready to Host The Naughty List Christmas Game Night?

Now that you have everything you need, from Reindeer Games and invitations to decorations, Christmas food, cocktails, music, and hosting ideas, it's time to gather your friends and find out who really belongs on Santa's Naughty List.

Will the Nice figure out who has been deceiving them? Will they accidentally banish their own allies?

Or will someone who has spent the entire night insisting they're obviously Nice make it all the way to the Final Decision?

The Naughty List from Game Nights Galore includes the materials needed to run the experience, including Host Guides, game setup information, Reindeer Game instructions and puzzles, Role Cards, Reward Cards, a Host Timeline, tracking materials, optional voting cards and name tags, and separate Naughty and Nice Guides.

Gather your friends, wrap the presents, pour the drinks, and start questioning exactly how Nice everyone has really been this year.

One last question:

Are you sure you know who's on the Naughty List?

The Naughty List Game

$25.00

Buy Now